Vegan in the Hamptons: Tutto Caffe
Address | 55 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937
On a warm summer afternoon in the Hamptons, sometimes all you want is a light meal, a good coffee, and a space that feels relaxed yet special. This is exactly what we found at Tutto Caffe, a charming café tucked into the heart of East Hampton that has quickly become a favorite stop for locals and visitors alike. With its understated elegance, thoughtful menu, and welcoming vibe, Tutto Caffe offers a fresh and modern take on the classic café experience—one that’s refreshingly friendly to those of us looking for vegan and plant-based options.
We stopped in on a sunny day for something simple: iced coffees with oat milk and thick slices of focaccia with roasted tomatoes, basil, and olives. What struck us immediately was the attention to detail, not just in the flavors but in the atmosphere. This isn’t your grab-and-go coffee spot where the espresso is rushed and the pastries are an afterthought. Tutto Caffe is carefully curated, from the quality of its beans to the warm, inviting décor.
A Coffee Experience with Intention
The iced coffee was smooth, bold, and perfectly balanced—not the watered-down version you sometimes find in busy coastal towns during summer. Made with care and finished with oat milk, it was refreshing and indulgent without being heavy. For anyone who’s ever been stuck with a splash of plant milk that curdles or overpowers the coffee, you’ll appreciate how seamlessly Tutto Caffe integrates non-dairy alternatives into its drinks. Oat milk, with its creamy texture and naturally sweet notes, complemented the coffee beautifully. It’s a small detail, but one that demonstrates the café’s awareness of what today’s customers are looking for.
Coffee culture in the Hamptons can sometimes lean toward the flashy—branded cups, crowded counters, and quick service meant to move lines fast. Tutto Caffe takes the opposite approach. The pace feels European, where lingering over your espresso or cappuccino isn’t just tolerated but encouraged. Sitting down with an iced coffee here feels less like a quick caffeine fix and more like a chance to breathe, to people-watch, and to enjoy the rhythm of a Hamptons summer afternoon.
Focaccia That Feels Like Summer
If the coffee was a highlight, the focaccia sealed the deal. Freshly baked, airy yet satisfying, and topped with roasted tomatoes, basil, and olives, it was a plate that tasted like the essence of summer. The tomatoes had that rich sweetness that only comes from being roasted until their natural juices caramelize, the basil was bright and fragrant, and the olives added a briny punch that tied everything together. It’s the kind of dish that demonstrates how simple ingredients, when treated with care, can shine.
What made it especially exciting was how effortlessly vegan-friendly it was. Often, vegan diners in the Hamptons are forced to edit dishes—“hold the cheese,” “remove the aioli,” “substitute the butter.” At Tutto Caffe, the focaccia needed no alteration. It was satisfying, flavorful, and plant-based right from the start. That’s the sweet spot for vegan dining: meals that don’t feel like they’re missing something, but instead showcase the best of what’s in season.
Summary: Best Vegan Picks
When it comes to vegan-friendly choices at Tutto Caffè, there are a few standout options that make it easy to enjoy a light meal or drink. The Olive e Mandorle—a mix of olives and almonds with orange zest—is naturally vegan and a perfect savory snack, while the Green Juice offers a refreshing blend of plant-based ingredients like apple, celery, cucumber, spinach, ginger, and lemon. For coffee lovers, the Shakerato becomes vegan when made with almond or oat milk, and the same goes for most of their iced teas, lattes, and coffees if you request a non-dairy milk substitution. Their homemade lemonades and sparkling lemonades are typically vegan as well, though it’s worth asking if they’re sweetened with honey. Finally, the focaccia topped with roasted tomatoes, basil, and olives is a highlight, but if you’re considering other varieties, be sure to check whether the pesto contains dairy and ask for modifications if needed. This balance of ready-to-go vegan options and customizable dishes makes Tutto Caffè a welcoming stop for plant-based eaters.
The Spirit of Tutto Caffe
There’s an Italian sensibility running through Tutto Caffe that goes beyond the menu. It’s in the café’s balance of sophistication and ease, the way the space is designed to invite you to linger, and the way the food honors both tradition and seasonality. While the menu isn’t exclusively vegan, there are clear choices for plant-based eaters, and the staff is happy to accommodate. Pairing a light bite with an expertly made coffee feels like the perfect formula for a Hamptons café, where long beach days and social gatherings are balanced with moments of quiet retreat.
Why It Matters
The Hamptons is known for its seafood shacks, upscale bistros, and farm-to-table restaurants, but vegan dining can still feel limited, especially if you’re looking for casual stops that don’t require a reservation or a full dinner commitment. Tutto Caffe fills this gap. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a coffee and a snack between errands, meet a friend for a light lunch, or simply sit with a book and enjoy the afternoon.
For those embracing plant-based eating, whether full-time or just occasionally, Tutto Caffe is proof that the Hamptons is evolving. It shows that vegan options don’t need to be complicated or hidden at the bottom of a menu—they can be front and center, crafted with care, and appealing to everyone. After all, who wouldn’t love a slice of focaccia that bursts with the flavors of ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, and salty olives?
Final Thoughts
As summer unfolds in the Hamptons, finding little pockets of joy becomes part of the experience: a stretch of empty beach at sunset, a roadside farm stand with peaches still warm from the sun, or a café like Tutto Caffe, where a simple iced coffee and focaccia can feel like an indulgence. For vegans and plant-based eaters, it’s reassuring to know that options like this exist—places where the food is vibrant, the coffee is excellent, and the atmosphere invites you to stay a little longer.
Tutto Caffe may not market itself as a vegan café, but it embodies the kind of inclusivity and quality that makes dining here a pleasure for everyone. Whether you’re in East Hampton for the weekend or the whole summer, it’s worth stopping in. Order an iced coffee with oat milk, savor a slice of focaccia, and let yourself slow down for a moment. That’s what being in the Hamptons is all about.
